Benefits brokerage · 3 offices
COTTINGHAM & BUTLER INSURANCE
COTTINGHAM & BUTLER INSURANCE is named as the broker of record on 164 insurance contracts across its 3 offices in public Form 5500 Schedule A filings.
Offices
Largest book first.
A contract that names two offices of this firm is counted on each of their rows, so this column adds up to more than the firm's own total. The total counts each contract once.
| City | State | Contracts |
|---|---|---|
| DUBUQUE | IA | 161 |
| MADISON | WI | 2 |
| No city on file | — | 1 |
Book profile
COTTINGHAM & BUTLER INSURANCE brokers 164 insured contracts for 115 employers, across 26 states, led by IA, WI, IL.
Vision is the largest line (56 contracts), followed by disability (53), life (52), dental (48).
METROPOLITAN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY writes the most contracts in the book (70, about 43%); RELIASTAR LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY, EYEMED VISION CARE, EYEMED VISION CARE ON BEHALF OF FIDELITY SECURITY LIFE INSURANCE CO. follow.
Renewals concentrate on January 1: 76% of the dated welfare contracts have policy years ending in December, so most of the book comes up for review at once.
Contracts in the book, by the carrier that writes them. Largest first.
Counted by each employer's own state. Largest first.
Contracts by line.
vision 56 · disability 53 · life 52 · dental 48 · health 37 · stop-loss 1
Welfare contracts, counted by their typical renewal date (the 1st after the policy year ends). Annuity and GIC funding contracts have no renewal.
- J
- F
- M
- A
- M
- J
- J
- A
- S
- O
- N
- D
Clients on file
| Employer | Location | Office | Carrier | Renews |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| POKAGON BAND OF POTAWATOMI | DOWAGIAC, MI | DUBUQUE, IA | BLUE CROSS BLUE SHIELD OF MICHIGAN | Jan 1FY2023 |
| THOR INDUSTRIES, INC. | ELKHART, IN | DUBUQUE, IA | DELTA DENTAL OF INDIANA | Jan 1FY2025 |
| PACKERS HOLDINGS, LLC | KIELER, WI | DUBUQUE, IA | RELIASTAR LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY | Jan 1FY2025 |
| SAYERS TECHNOLOGY, LLC | VERNON HILLS, IL | DUBUQUE, IA | BLUECROSS BLUESHIELD OF ILLINOIS | Nov 1FY2025 |
| VETERINARY PHARMACY CORPORATION | DES MOINES, IA | DUBUQUE, IA | BLUE CROSS AND BLUE SHIELD OF MINNESOTA AND BLUE PLUS | Jan 1FY2025 |
more employers in COTTINGHAM & BUTLER INSURANCE's book
See the full client list across every office, with carriers, renewal dates, and disclosed commissions — plus the renewal calendar and export.
Sourced from U.S. DOL EFAST2 Form 5500 · Schedule A · each row is that employer’s most recent filing, largest premium first (plan years 2023–2025 on this page)