Form 5500 · Employee benefit plan · COLUMBUS, OH
FISHEL COMPANY
FISHEL COMPANY of COLUMBUS, OH spreads its employee benefits across 3 insurance carriers, according to its Form 5500 Schedule A. Its broker of record is COTTINGHAM AND BUTLER. Coverage is written through COMMUNITY INSURANCE COMPANY and 2 other carriers. The plan's most recent policy period ended in March.
Sourced from U.S. DOL EFAST2 Form 5500 · EIN 31-4360115 · plan 504 · as of Aug 2026
Plan brief
Schedule A lists 3 insured contracts covering health, dental, vision, life and disability; the largest, with COMMUNITY INSURANCE COMPANY, covers 3,640 people.
Reported premium across the insured contracts is $26,748,429, with $56,786 in disclosed broker commissions — about 0.2% of premium.
The health contract's policy period ended in March, while at least one ancillary line renews in December — the plan is on a split renewal cycle.
COTTINGHAM AND BUTLER is the broker of record on 1 of the 3 contracts; the rest name a different broker or none.
3 carriers appear on the filing — COMMUNITY INSURANCE COMPANY, ANTHEM LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY and MANHATTANLIFE — with COMMUNITY INSURANCE COMPANY writing the largest contract by premium.
Schedule A insurance contracts
| Carrier | Benefits | Covered | Renews | Premium | Commission |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ANTHEM LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY | Life, Disability | 2,483 | March | $920,410 | $56,566 |
| MANHATTANLIFE | — | 13 | December | $4,407 | $220 |
| COMMUNITY INSURANCE COMPANY | Health, Dental, Vision | 3,640 | March | $25,823,612 | $0 |
More employer plans in Ohio — largest plans, brokers, carriers and renewal months.